I went out on a limb today to try a type of beer that might just be the most intriguing I've come across: a pumpkin ale. Now, I love pumpkin pie. I love roasted pumpkin seeds. As a matter of fact I even like squash. The logical assumption is that I would also like pumpkin in beer form, right? Yea not so much.

My general opinion about the Hoppin' Frog
Frog's Hollow Double Pumpkin Ale is that it would only be good if you were eating a holiday meal, were someplace cold and sitting by a fire, and you had only one glass of it. The spices were overwhelming in a bad way. You could really taste both the pumpkin/squash flavor and the cinnamon, nutmeg, etc spices with every sip. As the beer got warmer I actually started to like it less. So much so that I stopped drinking it half way through. Even though I was not a fan of this one I do want to try some of the pumpkin ales from other brewers. There has got to be at least one that I like.
I'm also rather critical about the Frog Hoppin' website.... it seems a little 'hokey.' It honestly looks like someone put it together with a knockoff version of some template designer, and they threw up some random beer and frog related pictures/icons on there. Too many random looking colors, terrible layout, and they have frogs for bullet points. Tacky. Do better Frog Hoppin'. Then again, they are from Ohio...
Not only do I want to comment on today's beer, but I do recall saying that I was going to do a double post with info from the one I had [
yesterday]... the Left Hand
Stranger.
This one was much better than the one I just drank half off. It actually reminded me very much of the homebrew IPA I have kegged right now. I think that we used the same hops, and possibly grains, as Left Hand did. We weren't trying to clone that brew, but it was just so strikingly similar I couldn't help to think about it. The biggest difference between the two was the level of intensity in the hops (the IPA homebrew being more intense), the bitterness (the
Stranger was more bitter), and the mouthfeel (the IPA was more full bodied). You might read that and think "so, what you're saying is they were completely different?" Not the case.
I tried to come up with something comparable to describe it but what I wrote made no sense. I'm terrible at analogies. Anyways I liked the beer yesterday. It seemed like it would be a good 'all-day-drinking' type of beer because it had a very clean and dry finish with little aftertaste. The ratings I found online for it were rather low, but I'm willing and able to disagree. [For the record the
Double Pumpkin Ale got ratings in the 90's (out of 100) and I thought it was terrible.]
All in all my takeaway from the past few days of beers is that it can be a crapshoot when it comes to brewing beer that people like. I've made beer in my kitchen that people said they would literally go out and buy, and yet there is beer on the market that people buy and actually tastes like shit. What is really important [I think] is getting off the ground and to the point where you can make enough beer that allows you to create a demand for it. Then when you get the brand going you can almost brew up anything, call it a 'seasonal' or a 'specialty' and then people will buy it.

Believe me when I say that I will be taking note of this for the future...
Hoppin' Frog
Frog's Hollow Double Pumpkin Ale
Spice/Vegetable Ale
8.4% abv